Hillhead Jordanhill RFC 1st XV 14 pts ( 1 LB ) West of Scotland FC 1st XV 18pts ( 4 WB )
Bernie Mitchell
The smart chat being offered by the cognoscenti at the pre-match lunch was that the outcome of this Glasgow Derby was too close to call. And so it turned out : the narrow half time lead of 10-7 enjoyed by the visitors moved on to 18-14 at final whistle. Hills scored 2 tries, one each half with both converted , while West edged ahead with 2 tries again 1 in each half, 1 conversion and 2 penalty goals to take 4 league points home to Burnbrae while Hills earned 1 losing bonus point, finishing within 7 points of the victors.
This was a high intensity, well contested game with West marginally having the better of the first half due to superior line out possession and more effective direct running from their three quarters. Yet Hills, after a fierce opening quarter when West monopolised territory and both 1st and 2nd phase possession, stole the lead when Joe Stafford waltzed away from the side of a breakdown to run in unopposed to touch down between the posts to score. George Gornall, deputising for the injured captain, Rory Harte, at 10, added the extras. Hills gained confidence from the score and pressed hard from aggressive ball carrying from Lewis Lightbody , Liam Tighe and Jimmy Griffith, the veteran centre, but there was no way through. Then a speculative diagonal from the visitors stand off bounced awkwardly over the head of winger, Corrie Dicks, to allow West across the line via the back door. The try was converted and West were back in the contest. A thrilling passage of play from Hills then followed with Corrie Dicks in electric form, beating 4 defenders on his way to the line. However the momentum was lost due to a handling error, one of many which disfigured the Hills performance over the full 80 minutes. West reached the game’s mid point, adding a close range penalty goal.

The 2nd period started poorly for Hills with the visitors benefitting from very quick breakdown ball and 2 long passes providing their left winger with an overlap and a direct route to the line for his try. The conversion failed and West were now 8 points ahead with 30 minutes left to play. Hills answered the call to attack from all parts of the paddock with full back, Matt Murray, continually returning West’s deep kicks with electrifying runs. Hills recycled frequently but unforced handling errors undid the hard yards gained. Finally prolonged drives on the West line yielded an opportunity for 2nd rower, Jamie Banks, to burrow over to touch down with George Gornall converting.
It was now a 1 point game and West had lost a player to a yellow card for a deliberate knock down. Hills were again in the ascendancy, but when the try line beckoned another offload error led to an infringement. West cleared their lines, and then proceeded to manage the game out effectively to its conclusion by adding a penalty goal from within the home 22. At 18-14 West hung on to allow the admirable match referee, Stuart Wright, to blow for no side.

This National 3 league fixture, played in front of a decent crowd, was a fine advert for the health of the domestic game at this level. Well done to West for their victory and perhaps pause for refection in the home camp as to what might have been if their high intensity, offloading game had been sharper on the day.
Its now a “ welfare break” for this league and Hills revert to action in another Glasgow Derby when they travel to the Bearyards of Bishopbriggs to renew hostilities with Allan Glens on Saturday October 4, KO 15.00

